Made-From-Scratch Pies

Serving the St. Louis area since 2012



2719 Sutton Blvd

Maplewood MO 63143

Contact Us



Call To Order

Store Hours


Thursday - Saturday: 11 - 5

Closed Sunday - Wednesday

We are no longer accepting orders for Friday, Saturday, or Monday


Friday open 11 - 5 (or sold out)

mini pies and a few full pies


Saturday open 11-5 (or sold out)

mini pies and a few full pies


Monday open 10 - ? (until sold out)

Slices and full pies



The past two years have changed all of us, making us reevaluate where we are and where we want to be. After much consideration we have decided it is time to move on -- we are closing Pie Oh My.


Our final business day will be Pi(e) Day Monday, March 14.


It was a great honor that Jane trusted me to take the reins in 2016.  I greatly appreciate our longtime customers and meeting new ones, will miss the catch-ups and chats, and will especially miss our Maplewood neighbors.


Thank you so much for your support over the years!

What We Offer

For walk-in customers we offer several flavors of individual serving pies in two sizes: small, which is the size of a homestyle cupcake, and medium which is about the size of your palm.



We also have pie by the slice in two or three flavors every day. (On Saturdays we don't start slicing until after 1:00.)

Full-sized pies should be ordered in advance.


Although we usually have one or two full-sized pies in the store for slicing, the only way to guarantee that you get what you want is to order in advance. Call us at least the day before with your request. 9.5", serves 6-8.


We also offer a 5" deep-dish size that can be ordered in advance (by phone). Serves 2-3.

Last Mini Pie Flavors of the week!

Mar 10 - Mar 12

(in store for small and medium mini pies only)

- Brown Sugar Pear

- Coconut Custard

- Caramel Apple w/Pecans

- Chocolate Chess

- Oatmeal Butterscotch


Small pies can be pre-ordered by the dozen per flavor, and Medium pies can be pre-ordered by the half-dozen per flavor.

Call the store to order!  314-704-4416 .    No Mini Pies on Pi Day


(If you want to order small or medium pies in smaller quantities per flavor, you will be limited to the flavors of the week -

Call the store to order)


About Our Pies

We use the very best ingredients like fresh fruit, Missouri pecans, and Belgian chocolate. Everything is made from scratch in our bakery: from dough to fillings we do it all right here!

We can accommodate special dietary needs such as gluten, sugar, or dairy-free -- call us with questions or to place your special order (we don't have these in store for walk-in customers). Note that your flavor options will be limited.

These flavors are for pre-orders of full pies only. Flavors in-store change weekly (see "flavors of the week" above)

Year-round Flavors   (Pre-Orders)  NOT FOR Pi Day


Apple Crumble

Apple Green Chili*

Caramel Apple Pecan*


Lemon Chess

Lemon Lavender

Lemon Meringue*

Chocolate Meringue*

Pear Apple

Pear Chai

Sour Cream Apple*

Almond Toffee*


Chocolate Bourbon Pecan*

Chocolate Chess

Coconut Chocolate Walnut*

Gooey Butter

Hazelnut Caramel Coffee*

Oatmeal Butterscotch

Oatmeal Chocolate

Oatmeal Maple Walnut *

      w/Schlafly Stout

Orange Maple Walnut*


Toffee Gooey Butter

Almond Custard*

Brown Sugar Custard

Cherry Custard


Pear Custard

Pear Almond Custard*

Chocolate Hazelnut*

Bailey's Chocolate Cream*

Banana Cream

Butterscotch Cream

Chocolate Cream

Chocolate Malt Cream

Coconut Cream

Key Lime

Lemon Cream


Call to Order

*Premium Flavors

Looking for Boston Cream Pie?    Boston Cream Pie is cake, and we don't make cakes!

About Us

Pie Oh My was formed in 2012 by Jane Callahan, first selling her pies at farmers markets, then opening the location in Maplewood. Melennie Lorence joined the staff in 2013, and in April 2016 took over ownership of the bakery.


Six Kittens Baking is our company name, but Pie Oh My is the bakery. That's why you'll see "Six Kittens Baking" on your receipt.

Copyright © 2021 Six Kittens Baking LLC. All Rights Reserved.